Anthony's New York Pizzeria

Anthony’s New York Pizzeria in Greer is the real deal. The staff was incredibly friendly and very helpful, and the service was outstanding from start to finish. They were running a two-slice and a drink special, which is an unbelievable value. I had the Margherita slice and the Grandma slice, and both were excellent. The crust was absolutely perfect — cooked just right with that ideal balance of crisp on the outside and soft, chewy texture inside. You can immediately tell they know how to make true New York–style pizza. The Margherita slice really stood out — the seasoning and tomatoes were incredible, fresh, flavorful, and perfectly balanced. Every bite was packed with taste without being overwhelming. I also tried their shrimp scampi which was amazing, and the meal came with a garlic rol

I follow many Facebook foodie pages and Anthony’s is one of the top choices for a lot of pizza posts. The hype is there. The pizza was perfectly cooked, crispy, and flavorful. The [fresh] garlic knots were great, and the chicken parm plate was HUGE. Could easily feed two people and then some probably. While it’s not a typical restaurant style, there is plenty seating available. You do place your order up at the counter. The service was great and we were attended politely. Definitely see why Anthony’s is at the top of a lot of people’s lists.

We tried Anthony’s for the first time and it is absolutely delicious! Pictured is the chicken parm, great flavor and quality especially for $14 or if you get the lunch special it’s like $8-$9 which is unheard of. The chicken is perfectly breaded, the sauce is incredible and I loved that there was fresh basil on top! I think got the chicken cutlet sandwich and added bacon and onions. It was so good, I wish there was a little more chicken to the bread ratio but it was one of the best sandwiches I’ve had. We also ordered a slice of pepperoni pizza, that was ridiculously good, loved the type of pepperoni they use! Last but not least we also ordered the baked ziti which was wonderful and cheesy! My husband said he would add a chicken cutlet next time (that’s how good their chicken cutlets a

Order “The Emily” for us and a cheese pizza for the kids today! We paid $39 and some change. These pizzas are HUGE and so full of flavor and worth the money! We absolutely LOVE Anthony’s! It’s our favorite pizza place in Greer. Tastes very authentic and fresh! It’s always been a great experience.

This is easily my favorite place to get pizza locally. You can taste the quality and effort put into every slice. A lot of their desserts are homemade and I haven’t had one I didn’t thoroughly enjoy. The tree leche cake is especially good. The staff has always been so friendly, welcoming, and kind. Thankful to have Anthony’s close to my home!