Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings

This is not NY pizza and in my personal opinion not good pizza. Wasted almost 50 bucks for 2 pizzas with barely any sauce, cheese that was cooked so hard the top of the pizza was becoming a cheese crisp and then the crust had no chew to it. It was like a cracker shell. Not to mention it left my hands looking like I did a shift in the coal mines from how burnt it was. This might be suited for travelers looking to have a “healthier” NY style pizza but if you’re a native New Yorker take my advice and go elsewhere. There’s at least a dozen other places I know on Long Island that do a real NY pizza for cheaper. I took a gamble on it so I’ll swallow the loss but fair warning to my fellow Nyers

Sept 2025: 5 star review. sat down inside and was treated perfectly. It was three of us. The waitress was so nice. The food was absolutely perfect. The garlic knots were the best knots I’ve ever had. Cheesy and garlicky perfection. Would order these every single day. Ordered 16” Paulie’s pie with pepperoni. It did not come out burnt. The taste was perfect!!! Also order buffalo and garlic parm wings. The buffalo sauce was out of this world. The garlic parm was average but still tasty. I have to say I would return. August 2025: was a 4 star review. Ordered online and did a pick up. Pizza tasted yummy but lots of the pizza was burnt from the coal fired oven. We couldn’t eat the crust. Otherwise, great flavor

First time to this location, same stuff we loved at the Wantagh location. The well done wings and the well done pizza is what we are used to and this airport location does it just as good. We have been ordering the cauliflower pizza for years and just love the combo! The wings with onions is a signature combo for ACF too, love them both. We were greeted upon arrival for our p/u, and shortly after we were on our way home to enjoy our two favorites! No stars for atmosphere since we didn't stay, but check the pic for yourself. I'd recommend Anthony's keep the area behind the counter a little cleaner...(see pic).

The wings, delicious especially the little burnt pieces with the sauce. It's like bbq. Not too thrilled with the pizza, I was looking for more flavor. The atmosphere was nice, just a little too dark for my liking. I also didn't understand why each waitress/waiter walked by a table that wasn't cleaned. We arrived at 6pm left at 7pm, and the table was never cleaned. That was strange. Needless to say the service was good for a table of 5, to order, eat and leave in an hour, not bad.

UPDATE: The snow removal on the front side was much better after my following visit, and there was rock salt applied often, thank you! Original: The pizza is delicious. The service is great but sometimes slow. The place is nice and clean. I go there often so I really enjoy it. But yesterday I risked my life for it. Icy outside, no salt was put down out front, and the shared parking lot was a sheet of ice.