Andys Hometowne Pizza

The food was pretty good, but they didn’t put toppings on half of my pizza even though I ordered a whole topping pizza.

Super good! Walked over for lunch from the hotel nearby. I had the chicken Piada (pea-ya'-dah); a baked sandwich folded like a calzone - YUMMY! Plain and simple dining room. It seems their business is mainly carryout and delivery, but the place is very clean. I fully enjoyed my food and having the whole place to myself. ☺️ ... won't be around to try the Monstrosity Challenge though it sounds fun.

We stopped ordering Andy’s probably 7 years ago due to them forgetting to make pizzas and messing up orders. Their food is good, but it was annoying to show up for pizza pickup only to never had pizza even made. Fast forward to 2025 we decide to give it another chance and wouldn’t you know, we pull up for pickup and our pizza is not there. It’s in their system, just wasn’t made/lost/forgotten, who knows.

Writing this review while waiting for my order since I have extra time. When ordering online, don't show up when your order says it'll be ready, cuz it won't be. Frustrating. I show up at the time it says in my email confirmation (which was ordered ahead) and she tells me it'll be another 10-15 min. What was the point of ordering ahead? The helpless lady at the register even told me the times aren't correct for online orders. Might be a good idea to fix it; since it's 2025.

Always a delicious pizza! Our go-to for take-out pizza night and I’m always sad I didn’t order more. Fast service too!