American Pizzeria

American Pie Pizzeria has become a favorite spot for our family! From the moment we walk in, we’re always greeted with friendly smiles and a cozy, welcoming atmosphere. The service is consistently top-notch — they treat you like family every time. And the food? Absolutely delicious! Whether we’re grabbing a classic pepperoni pizza or trying one of their specialty pies, everything is fresh, flavorful, and made with care. It’s the kind of place where you can relax, enjoy a great meal, and make memories with the people you love. We’re so thankful to have a place like this in our community — it’s more than just a pizzeria to us. Highly recommend!

Butter balls? Yes... Dough balls in a vat of garlic butter! Yes... yes... And Yes! Pizza was great.... Light... Crispy crust... Also serve yourself drinks which is so much easier! We had picked out the diner next door but there was a 45.min wait.... Glad we just walked into this pizzeria!

This place has truly great food. Great and fresh pizza, spaghetti, wings. My only dissatisfaction is the customer service. They're not as pleasant. They dont make you feel welcome to their establishment, and essentially thats the model of thr atmosphere. Besides that, food is magnificent and I'll keep coming back 😋

Pretty good. A nice change from the usual restaurant pizza taste. I had the calzone. My wife had the small American Pie. The calzone could use a little garlic butter or seasoning on the crust but once you dip it in the sauce it's pretty tasty. The pizza has a nice taste as well. The buffalo butter bites were different. I will have to try buffet next time. Customer service was nice and friendly. Cool atmosphere too. Your boy The RIBOLOGIST IS OUT ✌🏾.

Great pizza, hot and fresh. Wife and kids love the butter balls. Fast service. Good value for family of five. Dined in tonight (Sunday). Only two slices left of 18” pizza greatness. Yum yum!