Amato's Sandwich Shops

Yesterday my husband and I got food at this amatos. We live 45 minutes away and had other things to do in area. Our food was delicious. What was upsetting and took away from experience was the dining room was closed and it was 5pm on a Saturday and I guess that also means we weren’t allowed to use bathroom. We will likely return but may not order food if dining area and restrooms are closed. It’s just really challenging eating pizza and salads in the truck in winter. It’s ok though there are other pizza places in area that still allow sit down. Hoping our next visit we are allowed to eat inside.

Windham Maine never disappoints! The counter staff who takes our order is always kind and patient and asks things like, "Is there anything else I can get for you?" or "Will there be anything else?" Never felt rushed or felt like an inconvenience. Drink coolers are always well stocked. Sandwiches are always well stuffed with fresh veggies and meats. Dine in area is always clean. I have never used the bathrooms but my kids say it's clean and well stocked. Keep up the good work!

Has the Windham store come under new management? I went here today and also last week after not eating there for a few months. I always get two dozen hot wings because this location has always made them crispy. No other Amato’s I’ve been to can get the wings right the way this store does. However, after going twice in the last two weeks, the wings have been pathetically small. Every single wing was no bigger than my pinky or the tip of my thumb. I was charged the regular price for what is, in reality, far less chicken meat. At first, I thought maybe it was just a fluke—sometimes stock issues happen. But I ordered another two dozen today and it was the exact same thing: all small, TINY wings. I also usually get the buttercup pudding when it’s available. It’s typically smooth, thick, and

They need to slow down. Half of my sandwich was wrapped up between the layers of the paper. Take an extra 10 seconds and put the sandwich together, have a little pride in your job. Also they need to learn to cut the vegetables. Some pieces are paper thin, or you gt half an entire pickle

I cannot go on any longer and not give my honest review. I genuinely believe the only people on the planet that enjoy Amatos have never stepped foot outside of Maine. As a Mainer , I have done my fair share of traveling and can tell you Maine Sub shops in general are sub par. But Amatos is one of the worst. Cheapest ingredients and the worst Sub roll bread on the planet. Why would anyone want an Italian or a Blt or any sandwich on an oversized hot dog bun????? Every single time ive gotten a sandwich its like an open faced style, falling all over me as I eat. Terrible. Wouldnt recommend. Picture speaks for itself.