Amato's Pizza

I don't typically write reviews, but felt compelled to this time. The Pizza: With a myriad of options for pizza in the beach area, this one is the best (especially for vegans). Clearly uses fresh authentic ingredients which are reflected in the taste and texture. Their Sicilian pie is incredible. It's light yet filling. Leaves you more than satisfied without that "weighed down feeling." Their round pie is excellent as well. Great crunch on the underside with a perfect balance of savory and sweet from the sauce. The owner is a really cool accommodating guy. Certainly is passionate about the food he makes and making customers happy. This is a really good small business to support. I don't get Pizza often, but when I do, I go to Amatos.

This is a great pizza. Perfectly crispy, flavorful, and the sauce is very nice. The guys were very busy but still made time to talk pizza for a minute!

Grabbed a few pies for a get together and loved them. Miss my New York pizza I grew up with but this was dang near close. Loved the char as well

Best Margherita pizza I've ever had in my life, the sauce was amazing, the crust was crispy, it was delicious, it was PERFECT! The canolis were out of this world too! Super friendly, excellent customer service, and a very cool vibe inside.

A lot of hype for Amato's, with good reason. Amato's opens up later in the day so if you're wanting it for a timely dinner, either place an order online the day before, or roll the dice calling in! Increase your odds of prompt pizza by showing up in person. The pizza was a little thicker than a New York slice, the sauce was tasty and cheese perfect. We also got the pepperoni rolls. Both the 16" pizzas and 2 pepperoni rolls were completely devoured in no time. First time getting Amato's, and now a new favorite pizza in Bethany. If you want to try it, plan ahead by ordering the day before or get there in person then they open. 🍕 🔥