All Star Bagel

A great bagel shop in the Tuckerton area that has become our go to spot for Sunday breakfast! We love their bagel selection, bagels, schmear options, friendly staff, and their quick convenient service! Their breakfast sandwiches are also delicious and fast!

My daughter got married this weekend at the LBI National. The Inn there does not provide breakfast, so I contacted James from All Star Bagel and put in an order with a lot of special requests. We had people from 6 states and Canada, some were gluten free, many never had a "jersey bagel". James recommended we try, in addition to the traditional favorites of everything, plain, cinnamon raisin and sesame, that we try pumpkin and cranberry. James delivered the bagels, which were still warm. They smelled amazing! These were THE BEST bagels I have ever eaten! And I've had bagels in north Jersey, NY and Montreal. In particular, the cranberry, was next level. I tasted notes of orange and the little bit of sugar on top made this an incredible, very unexpected delight! I ordered 4 d

This spot is hands down one of the best bagel places around. The bagels are always fresh, soft on the inside, perfectly toasted, and the breakfast sandwiches are stacked. You can tell they actually care about quality. Super clean inside and the staff is friendly and quick. If your looking for a morning bagel spot and it’s not Allstar, your settling for less!

Maybe the cutest bagel shop I’ve ever seen! The staff is super friendly and bagels are delicious. I love that they have other breakfast options as well. My waffle was the best breakfast I’ve had in a long time! I also love that they have Apple Pay - can’t beat the convenience! Happy to have a new breakfast spot.

Got a couple pork roll egg white and cheese bagel breakfast sandwiches, they were tasty, but I was a little surprised at the price. $22.09 out the door for two of them.