Alfano's Pizza

Consistency is a major part of any restaurant, and this place really struggles. My wife and I love their taco pizza when it's good. Flavorful taco meat, other toppings and chips. It is a crap shoot though. We ordered last night, and got the bad. Barely enough taco meat on the whole pizza to make a single mini taco. The lettuce was wilted and the chips were stale. It was also extremely dry. We also ordered a pepperoni, black olive and jalapeno pizza. Unlike the taco pizza, this was flavorful, cheesy, and properly sauced. It was delicious. We keep ordering, because when they get it right, it's exceptional, but when they get it wrong, it's edible, but not enjoyable.

We decided to stop here after shopping and it was great. There is a small 2-seater table for dine in. Pizza was fantastic, perfectly crispy. Cookies were burnt on the bottom. Service was great - the cook was super friendly.

So Glad We Stopped In! We decided to get the Medium Unlimited and dine in — there was only one table, but this was our first visit and we wanted to try the pizza straight out of the oven. Wow, was it worth it! The crust was perfectly crisp, the toppings were generous, and the flavor was amazing. The staff was super friendly and welcoming, and you could tell they really take pride in what they do. Even though it’s mostly a carryout spot, it was such a great experience to enjoy it fresh and hot. If you haven’t tried Alfano’s yet, definitely stop by — it’s easily one of Wentzville’s best!

Absolutely amazing pizza! We arrived 30 minutes before closing and the owner was happy to make us a pizza and insisted we stay and eat it. It was delicious, fresh ingredients, amazing crust and large portion size. The hospitality and likability of the owner left a positive impression like the food. Definitely returning and sharing with others.

Best pizza in St Charles County! Never had anything that deserved less than 5 stars from here. The pizza and sandwiches are my favorite. Staff is always really cool and food is ready on time!