Addeo's Fire & Ice

Addeo’s Fire & Ice is the real deal. The pizza flat-out meets — and honestly exceeds — the New Haven Pizza standard. Beautiful char on the crust, great chew, balanced sauce-to-cheese ratio, and toppings that actually taste intentional, not just thrown on. You can tell this is made by people who care about the craft. And then there’s the cheesecake… phenomenal. Rich, creamy, not overly sweet, and the perfect way to end the meal. We went in expecting good pizza and left talking about both the pizza and dessert — which almost never happens. If you’re anywhere near Shelton and take pizza seriously, this place is absolutely worth the stop

Been here for 5 years living in Shelton and then Ansonia, and I finally came here. Plenty of parking outside and the service was amazing. The owners were so nice and friendly. Their thin crust pizza was amazing! Haven't had pizza like that in so long. We ordered regular cheese pie, meatball pie, and the all meats pie. They were so good, I highly recommend this spot! Defense buying pizza from here again! Thanks.

Had a great experience here while looking for a late night option. We were immediately with warmth and hospitality, and the menu was hard to choose from with so many unique options. Once order was placed, wandering the thrift shop was an awesome experience, found a couple of shirts for a great price and saw some cool items. We were treated to amazing water ice samples while we waited as well. The pickle based pizza I got tasted great, and I also tried an oreo cheesecake that was a hit. Will stop in again for sure the next time I’m in the area.

We stopped here before seeing a local show. There were a lot of options for types of pizzas and desserts. It was all homemade and the food was great! We got a 12” plain cheese pizza and it was delicious, it was thin crust. We didn’t have the opportunity to try their Italian ice, but heard it was amazing! Again, all homemade. The restaurant was very cool, but a little odd. There were board games, antiques, and just an overall interesting vibe.

Some of the best pizza I have ever had. The owners are awesome people who create an amazing atmosphere and incredibly food & desserts. The connected thrift store & book store makes this one of the coolest places I’ve been in CT.