Ye Olde Centerton Inn

Amazing hidden gem. Start with the calamari and end with the brownie!!! Every bite was delicious and perfect. Steak was a tad charred and gave the charcoal taste so that was something we would address next time but definitely plan to make this one of our top spots. MAKE RESERVATIONS! Pic is of the bone in pork chop and oh my its incredible

A Cautionary Tale! I felt like I was in a fever dream featuring high prices for unremarkable food. I was taken back to the 2000s and at the skating rink with Back Street Boys and Blue (Da Ba Dee) playing on repeat. The staff were friendly. I felt bad for them working at such a dilapidated establishment. They apologized for being “busy” but there were only 3-4 other small tables also there. Reservations are required even though the restaurant had plenty of empty tables with wrinkly table cloths. We went in on a Friday night were told to make a reservation and we did! Tons of details to check out. Peeling wall paper like a birch tree and dusty art work with large holes in the painting. The frames were crooked. Dusty electronic candles. We got a strange story out of the experience. Neve

I had the best birthday today! This restaurant is amazing everything was so worth the price! I had the centerton steak which was mouth watering! The server was so sweet and very knowledgeable about everything will definitely be coming back

We attempted to make a reservation for a party of 9 and were told they would not accommodate a group that size. This was surprising and disappointing, especially since we were trying to plan ahead and give the restaurant notice. There was no effort to offer alternatives, suggest splitting tables, or provide another option — just a flat refusal. I completely understand that space and staffing can be challenges, but the lack of flexibility or willingness to work with us was frustrating. We were ready to bring a large group and spend money there, but instead had to find another restaurant that was more accommodating. Unfortunately, as a local to the area this left a poor taste and won’t be back I rather give my business to a restaurant that is grateful and appreciates the business.

Bland food, but A LOT of it on the plate. Huge portions but a $7 sharing fee. Took home enough for dinner for the next 2 days, but no was excited about eating the leftovers. Loved the historic atmosphere. Only us and another table occupying the restaurant, but they chose to seat us right next to the other party which made conversation awkward in the quiet room.🤨 Not worth a 2nd visit, sadly.