Wyckoff Bagels LLC

I thought I’d give it a try as I was passing it rather than driving to my usual and favorite place, in Waldwick. It may have been towards the end of their day, but there was a super strong smell of cleaning solution. The bagel itself was OK, but they were skimpy on the cream cheese

I can’t believe that a business in North Jersey would have the courage to sell a Taylor Ham Egg and Cheese like this. I was in town for work, paid $16 for two of these with a large coffee and a small fairlife shake. When I got back to my desk I couldn’t believe what I was looking at. I didn’t have the ability to go back and complain, but this is disrespectful. How they could have 4 1/2 stars serving like this is beyond me.

They are the best because they’re the only bagel shop that actually LISTENS to your order. Toasted dark bagel? Done. Extra crispy bacon? Done. Add little butter? Done. Any other place you go to, they would miss one of the above. And their bagels are delicious. Not too fluffy, not too thick.

I just picked up this sandwich and it is absolutely horrible It has no flavor bc it's so thin that all you taste is bread. ALSO THE PERSON WHO I GOT GREETED AT THE COUNTER HAS NO PERSONALITY. No greeting and when I asked for extra napkins she handed me a meantime there was nothing in bag either. Do yourself a favor and go anywhere else then this place.

This has been my favorite bagel shop for years but I’ve been increasingly disappointed the past few trips by the tiny amount of cream cheese being put on these bagels. This is a quarter of the amount of what it used to be :/