Wittich's Candy Shop

On Thursday, I stopped and they had to sign up that this peanut brittle was not burnt. It was just the coloring no it’s totally burnt and disgusting. Probably the worst peanut brittle I’ve ever had look at the pictures you can tell it’s burnt, but of course she couldn’t see that when you were in the store because they had it all facing down.

I forgot to post a review when I went home to visit last year! We stopped in to get buckeyes to take back to Connecticut and grabbed a bunch of other goodies while we were at it. Our favorite treat was actually the pumpkin sundae! Look how cute! We’ve been trying to recreate it ourselves until we can visit again. Fingers crossed we can actually get in the door during Pumpkin Show!

Super easy to find and such a worthwhile stop! The candy is so yummy! We got some buckeyes and milk chocolate caramels- I also got a Christmas present and they offered free wrapping! My son ate his Santa chocolate lollipop before we were out of the parking lot. The staff were all super friendly and helpful. There was a steady stream of customers. We visited around 11 am on a Saturday. Plenty more f parking close to the store and it was super easy in and out.

This shop is an absolute DELIGHT! The ladies working are so sweet. They showed my kids how buckeyes are made and even let us have a sample. Of all our recent summer adventures, my kids said this stop was their favorite. ❤️ It’s rare to find truly handmade candies these days. Buckeyes and salted dark chocolate caramels are our favorites so far. We’ll be back for more!

For the past 30 years, my mother-in-law has gotten me a 16 oz box of all dark chocolate, maple creams because it is my all time favorite. This year, there is something off with the maple cream – so much so that I threw all but 4 away. MAWGA – Make Wittich’s Great Again!