Wings To Go - New Castle

These wings were RIDICULOUSLY SMALL and overcooked!!! No way they came from full grown chickens. Definitely not worth the pricebajd they should be ashamed to serve wings like this...WILL NOT GO BACK!!!

Stopped in for some Buffalo garlic wings. I like the wings here. They have a variety of sauces. Tables are available if you’d like to seat and eat. Now a long wait if you don’t phone ahead.

Post date 10/24/25. I hate posting this because I’ve always been a big fan of Wings to go.I use to eat here all the time. But the quality has went to hell. I ordered 8 wings but wings were so small the girl said she gave 10.to make up for it. Also The last few times I noticed the wings are being precooked and sitting in a basket over the fryer. Instead of cooking to order they’re being reheated. That’s making them overcooked and drying out. I talked to a manager about it She said that isn’t supposed to happen that they only precook the wings on busy day like the Superbowl. But this is the second or third time in the past month I watched the cook take them out of a basket full of wings. I ate in the store and the same two baskets of wings where sitting there for the 30-40 minutes I was e

I’m gonna give three stars out of five and the reason for this is because about a month ago I came to this location and ordered eight wings. The wings were so good that I was in there the next day and ordered another batch and I started to eat there about twice a week. I ordered wings today I did receive eight individual wings the only issue was they were so small. I bet you I was done eating within not even two minutes that’s how small they were and as I was throwing my trash away I was starving still. On 5/20 I Returned to wing a to go. I have visited this location 2x since the lunch letdown. It was a total 180! The wings were great the last 2 x I Visited. If I had to review the wings again, it would be a 5 stars.

Horrible!!! I will NEVER!!! order again. On 2/17, I ordered 24 traditional wings to go. When I opened the container at my friends house, I was horrified to find it all unedible. Weird looking chicken parts, wing pieces with no meat just skin and bones and a small fried spine with ribs attached from god knows what animal!!! I called them and took them back. No manager there. The guy at the counter looked in shock when I opened the box and showed him. Saw them cooking more wings. Just dumping them frozen from the bag into the fryer breaking them apart with tongs. Charging good money for cheap, miniscule wings. I added a picture of them. NEVER AGAIN!!!