Willie's Pizza

I just stopped at a competitor's location before coming here. I had recently finished watching Dave Portnoy's review of this place, where he walked out of the gas station lobby, which houses the pizza shop. When he gave it a respectable score of 8.1, I knew I had to try it for myself. I arrived at the gas station with my Ah-Beetz pizza in the front seat. Upon entering, I looked for Willie, but I was told he was in Colombia. I ordered my slices, and it wasn’t long before my pie was ready. After taking my first bite, I instantly realized that the pizza in my front seat was good, but not as good as this one. The crust was better, and the flavor profile was elevated. This is not something one would expect to come out of a gas station. Great!Find!

What a gem of a find. In a sea of just ok pizza in Florida, I hit the jackpot across from the sea in a gas station! I’ve had the pizza before, but now fresh out of the oven sitting in the gas station chatting with Willie’s friends who are helping him running the place under his guidance it was the best!! Went to get gas - saw a guy eating outside and so glad I listened to his advice to grab a slice! Go grab the best slice of pizza ever!

NY guy here — this is legit. Thin, crisp, great fold. Sauce and cheese exactly where you want it. Blindfold test, you wouldn’t know you’re not in New York. Dave and Justin behind the counter are awesome too. Willie’s — solid slice. 🍕

Pizza is excellent and as advertised. Best pizza south of NYC. And yes, I gave it 5 starts for atmosphere because the crew running it are so pleasant to deal with. The banana peppers are a must.

Favorite pizza in the area! Lived in NYC for several years and just haven’t been able to get my fix anywhere since living in Jupiter, until now!! The guys were also super nice. 10/10. Will be back over and over again.