Whistle Stop

We went out for a New Years dinner and I had the "Big Boy" prime rib. Absolutely delicious. It is a massive cut of meat and you will want to bring your "A-team" appetite... or take some home! The service was exceptional and my coffee cup was always full. Getting there early is a must because they fill up fast. This was arguably the most expensive item on the menu but hey, once a year it was certainly worth it!

Prime rib...ordered SEARED and medium, quite possibly the best prime rib I've had. About $20 cheaper than our second favorite in Green Bay at Rivers bend. Salad bar is better than average with a lot of red and green leaf lettuce servers are attentive and friendly.

All the locals rave about this place. However, our experience was less than pleasant. From a small sirloin that was rare on one end and charred on the other to a the big daddy prime rib that was ordered medium and came rare, but was still tough as leather. The waitresses hardly talked to us and they weren’t even very busy. We would rate the salad bar a 8/10 though.

Just some of the items you can get at Whistle Stop, formerly the Eagle’s Nest. Baby Back Ribs with Donna’s Famous Sauce, 12oz Ribeye & a “Broasted” Pork Chop with a twice baked potato. :0) #WhistleStop #MenomineeMichigan

Passing through on our way home to Menomonie, WI. Absolutely delicious. My husband and I love Supper Clubs and so glad we went. I had steak and was cooked perfect. He had the Ribs and fall off the bone. Highly recommend.