Whistle Stop Ice Cream Shop

Great ice cream set in a mock train station. The ice cream is rich and flavorful with especially great coffee flavors, chocolate and the base vanilla. Prices are very reasonable for the Cape and their sizes are generous. Service was fast and friendly and it has the true feeling of an old local shop. Definitely the place to stop in for ice cream in the area.

Excellent Ice cream flavor verity. Taste was amazing! The fudge sauce on our Banana Spilts was delicious and plentiful!

First time there and it was very nice. Will be back to try other flavors. My 92 year old mom loved her mint oreo.

Visited the Monument Beach shop yesterday afternoon, my family and I were so excited to see dairy free ice cream options! Sorbets and vegan flavors were awesome so yummy! Very friendly atmosphere and customer service 😊 Will be visiting again!

THIS is the homemade ice cream I'd been searching for all week!! Most of the places we'd been going to all week just resell pre-made Hershey's or other brands you can just get at the store, but you can taste the delicious difference between Whistle's and the others'. The service was also excellent, and the prices were very clear, unlike at other spots. Between the two of us, these were our thoughts on the 4 flavors we tried... Vanilla: 8/10 (vanilla flavor could have been stronger) Coffee Heath Bar: 8.5/10 (says it's super strong coffee flavor, but even kid's would like this; it's like the sweetest latte with bits of toffee) Chocolate PB: 9/10 Almond Joy: 7/10 (not as coconutty as I'd want; the coconut flavor was super faint) We'll be back next time we're on The Cape!!