Waterman's Tavern

I'm not impressed. In the picture, the dish with the fish and the chips was their $16 plate of ahi nachos. It was absolutely not worth it at all. I got it for half off and I was still disappointed. Is the ahi good? Yes. Was it worth $16 for 6 pieces? Nope. Not even close. I didn't really trust their non-american food so I went with a burger. It was cooked very well, but for some reason they decided that super thick cut uncooked onions was a good idea. It was not. The pickle was cut into a quarter so I just took it off because it was bigger than the burger itself. I don't know why they didn't just put on pickle slices. Got the mozzarella sticks, they were just fine. It's hard to mess them up. But for $10? Come on now. Bad presentation. The service was fine, I went on Monday night and there

We decided to pick a random place to try for lunch and this place did not disappoint. The cheesesteak was delicious and the crab pretzel was too. Our server was very nice and provided us with a welcoming attitude and great experience. We will definitely be back! Thank you.

Ordered the Mahi Fish Tacos with a side salad and a cheesesteak. The food was delicious and very filling! We could barely finish our meals. The pieces of fish were very thick, yet fit the taco perfectly. Reasonable prices too. Will definitely be ordering from here again. Seriously, give this restaurant a try!!

DURING SEVER WEATHER… I Door Dashed a cheeseburger and wings because I didn’t want to go out in the snow! Happy they were open so I am trying to be nice here! All the food was disgusting and tasted like it was 2 days old…….unacceptable! That’s the positive spin…… you decide!

I’ve been ordering from here on door dash. Me and my family love the jerk pita, quesadillas and fries as well as the pasta! The fries somehow still come crispy after delivery.