Wally's South 17 Supper Club

Great steak dinner. My filet was topped with a puff pastry (it was cold so it would be better if it were warmed up) & prime rib was perfect. I loved the glazed carrots! We had the warm, bread pudding for dessert, that was very good too. It was our anniversary, so it’s not an “intimate” setting for anything romantic. It’s a smaller restaurant, and we didn’t feel crowded at all, but if you’re looking for privacy, this isn’t your place. I don’t remember our servers name, however she was really good at her job, attentive & prompt. Our first time here & we will come back.

What took me so long to try this place? Absolute mistake. From start to finish, this place delivers. The steaks aren’t just good — they’re the best in Rhinelander. The cheese curds? Next level. And the bread pudding completely stole the show — a knockout surprise. Top-tier drinks, a staff that actually knows what they’re doing, and an owner who clearly takes pride in every detail. Stop thinking about it and just go. I should’ve been coming here a long time ago.

Another amazing dinner at Wally’s South 17. Changed it up and came on Saturday evening for prime rib. Perfectly prepared and melts in your mouth. Chose the baked potato that was perfectly cooked and added 4 large shrimp for an additional side. Hard to beat the service especially when Walt himself makes it a point to come speak to every table to make sure everything is done to your liking.

1st time visitors on pasta night , crafted cocktails were amazing! We had pasta and the parmesan shrimp , best shrimp ever ended the night with amazing bread pudding and cheesecake , Lexi was are server and was also wonderful , 5 stars all around we will for sure be back

We will definitely be back. Our waitress was the best! The Fisherman's Platter and the Perch Dinner was very tasty. But the dish you MUST TRY...THE BREAD PUDDING!!!