Tuscany NY Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria

Service was exceptional. If the parking spaces in front of the building are full, park in the back and come in the rear entrance. Was hoping for a piece of Mom’s Lasagna cut from a pan… (Google Maggiano's) What was served was tasty and had incorporated within all the necessary ingredients to qualify as hand made lasagna per the menu. Salad was fresh and bread was a nice addition. Enjoyed the meal. Prices reasonable.

First time they were actually open when came by. Never saw any advertising, just passed by and saw it. Been wanting to check it out several times but they shut down between a typical lunch and dinner service. This place doesn't scream Italian, more plain basic white cafeteria vibes. But don't let the looks fool you like it did me. The flavors are there and so is the service. I got the chicken marsala and even chose my pasta. Came quicker than I thought but the flavors were like it was cooking for hours. My server was great also. I've never had a server check on me as much as she did. Maybe because I was within the last hour before closing lunch but I'll take it Definitely want to try the other dishes knowing it will be full of flavor

Me and my fiancé came upon this restaurant while visiting the local town. The ingredients were fresh and the pizza was seasoned just right. Our waiter Lilly was an excellent server. We got all of this food for less than $60. We had a A+ experience. Food that was ordered: Small 10’ Margherita Pizza with spinach, Garlic cheese bread Side house salads Desserts: NY Cheesecake w/strawberry topping Tiramisu

First time eating here and I'll be back. The Shrimp Scampi was real good. The Pasta fagoil was good. Had enough of garlic bread for two other people and the side salad with the house dressing was tasty. The one thing that throwed me off was the fagoil. It had a strong bean taste but other than that, it was excellent

We stopped when in town for the first time. Finally found this Italian place. Our food and service was outstanding, can’t wait to go back and try another dish. I had the Chicken Marsala with angle hair, delicious. My wife had the Chicken Contadina, she loved it as well. We shared the Mussels Marinara. The were very tasty as well. Our server was awesome, very attentive and willing to please. Can’t wait for our return, thanks everyone! One of the best meals we have had in Lumberton, we have stopped at least 20 times on the way back from Florida.. 6/5/25 back again. Still 5 stars for food and service. Curran took care of us and provided excellent service. This time I had the pasta fagioli soup which was excellent. I also had the baked ziti and that too was awesome. My wife had a hogie which