Trattoria Natoli

We tried the Valentine special pizza along with a strawberry lemonade and a cherry limeade — and wow. Hands down, this is the best pizza we’ve had in Greeley. The pizza was absolutely loaded with flavor and way more filling than we expected. Every slice was satisfying, and we were full faster than we thought we’d be (which is never a bad thing when it comes to pizza). The Valentine special was a perfect choice — fresh, delicious, and clearly made with care. The strawberry lemonade and cherry limeade were the perfect refreshing pair to go with it. Both were flavorful and balanced — not overly sweet, just right. Safe to say, we’ve officially found our new go-to pizza place in Greeley. Can’t wait to come back and try more! 🍕🥤

Highly recommend this spot. The pizza is absolutely delicious—fresh, high-quality ingredients and perfectly suited to my taste. Be sure to try the lemonade as well; it’s excellent. Prices are very reasonable across the board. I will definitely be returning the next time I’m in town and visiting the Greeley Mall.

An absolute must if you’re in the area! Hands down one of our favorite pizza places no need for ranch either, pizza is great without it! Also love the lime ricky drink. When we are craving pizza you will find us here! Amazing service as well owner is very personable.

One of the best mall pizza places I've been to. The prices are affordable, the slices are filling and the lemonade is the CHERRY ON TOP especially with it being hand squeezed in store. Highly recommend if you're ever hungry or if you just need a quick thirst quencher.

Best pizza I’ve had in a long time! The hot honey made in house with the owners suggestion on our slices was so perfect and flavorful! And the cherry limeade was delicious along with the lemonade with like 3 whole lemons was amazing! Will definitely be back and will definitely be telling everyone I know about this place!