Tosco's Pizzeria

Cannot beat the prices here and I think they do the best slice & pizza in Rosendale plus they have a lot of other good stuff on the menu. Super friendly staff as well. It’s our go to for a pizza or a wrap.

We’ve been driving up from New Paltz for this pizza. For us Toscos has the right combo of thin slice, tomato & herb sauce, good cheeses, even cook across the pie and the large always seems huge! I also recommend their wings but am not a fan of their mozzarella sticks. I just wish they used different breading and could make them crispier. Not a make or break for me though. Also we’ve experienced great customer service there every time!

Thank you Stromboli and wings amazing yummy 😋 😍 Seriously size portions here are phenomenal.

I never had a problem with Tosco's they are awesome ppl and nice. I know a guy that works there he is great with ppl. Thank u moses.

The saddest pizza I’ve ever had in New York. I ordered a plain pie and a margherita pie. The margherita was embarrassing. Carelessly sliced pieces fresh mozzarella just haphazardly strewn about the pie, dusted over with a pinch of chopped up basil. Some of the slices literally had no basil on it (see the picture). The plain pie barely had any sauce on it. Might as well have been a grocery store frozen pizza. At least that would have been cheaper! The guy at the register also just straight up ignored me. Saw me standing there and just walked away.