Tony's Pizza

One of my favorite pizza places in the valley! My dad and I can easily crush a large square tray in one seating. Limited indoor space so we do takeaway, but also nice little seating area outside for the warmer weather days :). Pepperoni with extra sauce (it is delicious and sweet and unique) is the best!

Edit: Since the owners responded to my review, I bumped the overall review up to 5-stars. Keeping a good relationship with your customers is key for a business. Let me preface by saying the owners and the people working there have great personalities and are very welcoming. I've tried a couple pizzas there and it's hit and miss. My first time I ordered there (through DoorDash) I got the Boardwalk, hoping it would be similar to boardwalk pizza down by the shore where I grew up. I got their sauce on it only to find out their sauce is way sweet, so it made the pizza overly sweet with me. The crust was great though. Then I tried the New Yorker without the extra sauce and still, too sweet. I talked with the owner there and said to try the Old Forge Classic. I recently tried the Old Forge Cl

This little FAMILY OWNED, old school pizza (and other things) restaurant is awesome. The family is really nice. Love looking at the old black/white photos on the walls and The pizza? Forget it…KILLER. If you’re doing something since 1948, I think it is, you’re doing it very very well. Consistency is key. PS: The pizza is also awesome cold. Yes, I said cold.

The best sweet sauce!! Love all the pizza there. The new old forge style is amazing. A must try . We love it !!

I GOT SAUCED! A really solid Old Forge style pizza. I got the full tray with sweet sauce and got additional sweet sauce on top. I highly recommend.