Tony's Pizza & Italian Restaurant

TL/DR: Great food. Would I take a few minutes off of the interstate to come here? Yes. Would love to return. Food: Really large food selection. Check the menu. We had NY Style Pizze, Philly Cheese Steak, Fries. All were very, very good. Well prepared. Presented well. Left satisfied. Service: From the moment we came in, felt welcomed. Even when busy, we were taken care of. Atmosphere: A smaller restaurant. Located in a strip mall but still very nice. Should you venture 5 minutes off of I-64 for a bite to eat? Yes.

We have been ordering from Tony’s for years. There have been many mistakes but the owner always made it right. Tonight, both my husband and I were exhausted from work and decided to treat ourselves and the kids to delivery. Money is tight right now so this was a big deal. Unfortunately, my dish, the baked ziti romana, was completely inedible. The sauce either ‘broke’ or there was waaaayyyy too much butter put in and the ziti was so overcooked that when you tried to pick up a piece with a fork, it just shredded and fell apart. Mushy doesn’t even begin to explain it. It was absolutely horrible and after three bites I had to stop. I’m sick of calling to have things ‘made right’ so I give up. We won’t be ordering again. The oil/butter in the picture below is just a fraction of what was there.

After we were seated, the server did a great job attending to the order and following up throughout the service. The food was great! I had a stromboli and my wife had pasta with meatballs. It's not what you're typically known for, which is pizza, but we figured we would give some other dishes a try. They did serve wine and beer off a limited menu, but one portion was pretty generous. There's a reason why this place gets top marks from those in the area. We did have to wait for a little bit for a seat, but judging from the crowd inside and the numerous take out orders, this is a can't miss place.

This is a cute and very friendly restaurant! We visited during COVID, but they had a dine in option at 50% capacity as well as take out option. We decided to dine in. They were busy but it sounded like they had a lot of take out orders. The staff was super nice and pleasant to chat with. They were very good at making sure our drinks did not run dry. Shout out to our great server Alex. We got an appetizer of garlic bread. We also ordered a Stromboli and Manicotti. This place is very reasonably priced. We got an appetizer and two entrees for 28 dollars! In short we loved it. Per the boyfriend he says their marinara sauce is one of the best he has had!

Friday evening @ 5:30 and there was only a couple tables open. We almost turned around in the parking lot, but glad we stayed. Service was prompt, friendly and helpful, giving great menu options. Three at our table and we were served food within 20 minutes. I had the Mango Habenero Wings which were cooked perfectly and had great flavor.