Tony’s on the Mountain

Stopped in late at night while traveling and had a 10/10 experience! Hands down one of the best pizzas I’ve had in a long time. We ordered the Drunken Grandma pizza — the vodka sauce, fresh basil, and mozzarella were simply divine, all on a perfectly thin, crisp crust. Exactly what you want in a great pizza. The service was just as wonderful — friendly, fast, and welcoming. Highly recommend!

We ate at Tony’s while visiting the Poconos! We had a wonderful experience. We ordered the garlic bread with cheese, the antipasto salad and a pizza half pepperoni/ half sausage. Everything was so delicious! We even ordered a second garlic bread because my 9 year old loved it so much! Tony was awesome and let us know it was a new restaurant! We will definitely be back next time we are in the area and highly recommend! So friendly, great atmosphere, good prices and EXCELLENT food!

Since the new ownership took over in April 2025, this place has gone from good to fantastic. The food is absolutely delicious and consistently well-prepared. The pizza has a beautifully crisp crust with the perfect cheese-to-sauce ratio—just the way a great pie should be. The steak sandwiches are another standout—scrumptious, juicy, and cooked to perfection on fresh rolls. The fries are crisp, well-seasoned, and come with dipping sauces that complement them perfectly. Service is friendly, fast, and the new owners are often onsite, working hard and making sure every customer leaves happy. Their dedication shows in every bite and in the welcoming vibe of the place. Highly recommended for locals and visitors alike—Tony’s is clearly here for the long haul, and that’s great news for everyone

When we were being served, we were told “I think you over estimated the large calzone.” Indeed we did. The large calzone was enough for four people, so we were pretty happy about the price. It tasted good and we had leftovers for the next day. We think they should do a competition with this calzone. Who can finish it the fastest? We were some of the last customers of the day so the service was good. We will be back again in the future!

Cozy place with wonderful food. Staff is beyond helpful, especially, if you're coming through the review on google and you don't know the meal name, no worries at all, as we showed the picture to them, they immediately made the same meal, that was AMAZING!!!