Tony’s New York Pizza

This was our first time visiting Wildwood, New Jersey, and while the overall atmosphere in town was fair and the food at other places was just okay, discovering Tony’s Pizza truly made our trip special. We were all so impressed by the warm, welcoming staff and the outstanding service. We ordered the Grandmother’s Pie, a fresh mozzarella cheese pie, steak and cheese grinders, and some finger foods like mozzarella sticks and crispy buffalo wings. We also had a Caesar salad and a chef’s salad. Everything was absolutely perfect — fresh, delicious, and made with care. I’m not usually someone who writes reviews, but for Tony’s Pizza, I felt it was a must. If you’re ever in Wildwood, do yourself a favor and stop by — you won’t be disappointed!

We just got to wildwood from Virginia. My husband is originally from Philly and has always talked about missing tomato pies. We saw lots of good pizza places but Tony's had high reviews AND Grandma pies! It was easy to order online and we didn't have to wait long for it to be ready. My husband LOVED his pie. I like that it was not greasy or heavy. The cheese, sauce, and dough each had tasty balanced flavors. I enjoyed my meatball sub. Grateful to have such a great experience night 1. The staff was nice and provided plates and napkins when asked.

Ordered the vodka grandma pie, chicken fingers and garlic knots. Everything was awesome the grandmas pie was out of this world and the service was great!! Will definitely be returning.

After a long drive and a late arrival into town, all we wanted was a good bite to eat, and Tony's absolutely hit the spot. This place was a perfect find. We were starving, and Tony's delivered exactly what we were craving. Their pizza is fantastic—perfectly cheesy with a great crust. But the real star of the show might just be their steak sandwiches. Loaded with savory steak and fresh ingredients, they were everything you could want and more. If you're ever in need of a great, no-frills meal that truly satisfies, especially late at night, Tony's is the place to go. We'll definitely be back next time we're in town.

First night in town and my wife and I were craving pizza. We researched pizza near us and found that Tony’s Pizza had 4.7 stars so we thought we’d give it a shot. One of the worst pizzas I’ve ever had. Looked nothing like the pictures. The pizza was over cooked, very thin, very hard, and had no flex to it whatsoever (think cardboard). The sauce and cheese quality tasted like the cheapest around. Pizza is my favorite food, and I can slam down a large pie to myself, but I had one slice, she had one slice, and we threw it out. I wouldn’t expect much if the pizza was around 15 bucks, but for 24 dollars it was a complete waste of money.