Tony Pepperoni Pizza Bar

Come into Tony's for a great pizza. We ordered Tony's pepperoni with three different types of pepperoni, and it was excellent. The Cajun garlic wings were excellent as well. On Mondays you can get $1.50 cheese slices and $1.50 Rolling Rocks.

We went to Tony's for the first time recently and enjoyed it very much. Our party got a variety of items. From fried ravioli, chicken Parm sub, to pizza and wings. The taste was awesome on everything. Just the way we hoped it would be. If there was one thing I could change if I could, it would be the thickness ( or firmness ) of the dough of the pizza, but that's really a personal preference, not a critique. The dough itself was great. The wings were perfect, the chicken Parm sub was great and the fried ravioli was very good too. I wish we lived closer, because this would be a regular spot for us.

The food was delicious! The garlic knots were huge and covered in a delicious garlicy mixture We got the meat lovers pizza and it was very good with a sweeter red sauce and thicker crust, which I like. I will say it wasn’t very crispy so if you like a crispier pizza, you may not like it as much The Caesar salad was delicious and had a large portion of chicken on it. The meatballs were also delicious, again the red sauce they were covered in was very good. The service was amazing! The staff was so kind to us and very helpful. It was a smaller restaurant with not a ton of seating and one large outdoor table.

Toni Pepperoni is a classic hole-in-the-wall pizza spot with really good food at decent prices. Nothing fancy—just solid pizza done right. You can tell there’s pride in the place, especially since the owner is hands-on and managing day to day, which is refreshing to see these days. Friendly service, laid-back atmosphere, and food that keeps you coming back. A great local Mayport gem.

You become family as soon as you order. Pizza is great as are the Cajun ranch wings.