Toasted Turtle Tavern

Great food, great service, great atmosphere!

OK, I had scrambled eggs, bacon and biscuits and gravy full order. The gravy was really salty. The pepper bacon was overcooked and tasteless. I think because it was overcooked and the scrambled eggs were cold like they sat in the window a little too long but the biscuits were good. The service and atmosphere was pretty good.the food was not up to the Price

Night shift nurses found our new favorite post-shift breakfast spot this morning! Drinks were delicious, food was great, and service was quick. Loved the dirty sodas for a fun option for non-drinkers. Special shout out to Brenna, our awesome server. We will be back!

Amazing staff! Came in on a Sunday in the heart of craziness and they were very professional about everything. Food was very good. But the employees made it extra special

If you’re looking for one of the most unique brunch and dining spots in Elkhart, Toasted Turtle Tavern absolutely delivers. The interior feels fresh and modern, but what really makes the space special is the community-sourced memorabilia displayed throughout the restaurant. Instead of generic décor, the walls tell the story of Elkhart through items donated by longtime locals. It gives the place a character you won’t find anywhere else in town. The menu is just as impressive. Their brunch lineup is easily one of the most creative in the area, and everything feels thoughtfully prepared rather than rushed. From hearty breakfast plates to elevated tavern favorites, there’s something for everyone. Pair it with one of their drinks or cocktails and you’ve got a perfect weekend stop. What stands o