Thirsty Fellow Pizzeria and Pub

This was honestly one of the worst dining experiences I’ve had. It took over an hour and a half for our food to come out. After receiving food our server realized she completely forgot to ring in one person’s meal. Then it took almost another hour just to get our checks. Not once did she seem apologetic or take any accountability. The “Caesar salad” was just huge, uncut pieces of romaine with dressing dumped on top — no effort at all. Not to mention the prices were way too high for this level of service and quality. Definitely not worth it.

Our waiter was very good. Liked the atmosphere. A local pizza and beer place. A little sticky overall. Salads and sides were solid. Our two pizzas came out the same way - and bit undercooked and definitely very greasy. For convenience to campus and the college scene, it was fine.

Ordered a Caesar salad to go along with a pizza. The pizza was fine. But I guess I didn’t realize the salad was going to come deconstructed and without salad dressing? Kind of ludicrously disappointing considering it shouldn’t be hard to make just an average mediocre Caesar salad, but they somehow managed to miss that mark.

Worst bruschetta I've ever had. Really fantastic gorgonzola chips. One drink had no carbonation at all when it should have, while the fall cider was the best. Mixed feelings on this place overall. Might have been an off day.

Thirsty Fellow was pretty good! I'd say the two best things about Thirsty Fellow were definitely the atmosphere, and its proximity to Colonial Life Arena. It's a really convenient place to walk to after a game or event at CLA, and I loved how dimly-lit and relaxed it was, while still maintaining an old-school cool type of feel. As for the food, I'd say that it was "good." My pepperoni pizza and fries were above average, yet nothing particularly special. All-in-all, I would definitely recommend Thirsty Fellow, and I'll definitely be back in the future, probably during football season or after another event at Colonial Life!