Thimmes Fish Shack

One of the best hidden gems of Lancaster! Dine in or carryout. Oysters were fresh and DELISH!!

Highly recommend!!! The fish was delicious and tasted so fresh!! The cost is reasonable. The gentleman who took our order and served us is amazingly kind and polite! Child-friendly, parking is free, and great people to support! If I lived in the area, I'd go here more often! ><>

The owner was nice enough. Place was clean. All I ordered was two pieces of fish. It did not take long to get my order. But when I got home and opened up the bag and saw the fish. Wow was it small. The fish was cooked well enough but the batter was flavorless. I can’t say anything to the service, I didn’t eat in. I don’t think I’ll be back.

Good clams, better than most. Even better fish. Small fillets but perfectly cooked with a light, crisp batter. Well worth a trip.

Was pretty disappointed this visit, I have been eating Thimmes fish sandwiches for over 40-years and when you know how they taste and then something changes it's really obvious. The fish sandwiches had no flavor at all. 2 sandwiches 1 french fry and 1 can of pop was $17.39 .. i would be ok with that if the fish sandwich tasted like it once did. Not sure what you have changed but you changed something. Also, you need to turn the heat up some as it was very cold in the restaurant, we had an older couple next to us that kept their winter coats on they were so cold. I hope if you changed your fish, coating, buns or whatever that you go back to how it was before. Don't follow the trend of some places that raise prices but buy cheaper ingredients, it never goes over well with long time customers