Theo's Neighborhood Pizza

Great tasting pizza, has a seasoning on it that sets it apart from other places. Crust is somewhere between crisp and chewy. The Monday deal for pizza is hard to beat. Not sure I’d buy their pies at full price though. Service was a little less friendly than I’d hoped. Otherwise a good stop.

Went there. A few days ago and got the pepperoni and the supreme. Pepperoni was great. The people that ate the supreme ranged from average to good. Also had the house salad and the cheese bread. Both of those were good too.

Don’t order delivery with them. I ordered $90 ticket at 3:00 and didn’t receive it until 6. I asked the manager to contact door dash about it because she never offered me a refund. They remade my order, but didn’t follow up to make sure it was ever delivered, and when I told the manager it still hadn’t arrived (3 hours later) she said they have no control over what happens after it gets picked up. She hung up on me when I asked why they can’t contact DoorDash. Food was finally delivered 3+ hours later (I live 10 minutes away from them) cold and soggy. Sucks they didn’t care to hear the problem after a customer already paid, or offer a refund when it never showed up. We love theos and will prob go in person to a different location, but super disappointed they don’t care about customers or t

Lots of variety and delicious pizzas. Theo's is also taking precautions seriously. Hand sanitizer available up front, seasonings (e.g., crushed red pepper) come in individually wrapped packets. Bonus: large parking lot!

We usually order from Theos. However, recently Metairie store has been sorely lacking in quality. The small chicken pesto was skimpy on toppings and clearly over backed. In the past, it was tasty and sumptuous. The large pepperoni was not quite as over baked but still disappointing. So sad because we used to go there often. Will not go back. Too many other choices.