The Plimoth

Have been to the Plimoth almost 20 times over the past few years and there’s a reason we keep returning - outstanding food & outstanding service! We love to go heavy on the apps & share 1 entree as there’s always too many good ones to choose from! Rotating menu with what’s in season is always so fun. And Matt & the other bartending staff have curated some great cocktails! Couldn’t recommend more!

First time here and it was a lot smaller than I expected and feels more like a casual and fast dining experience. You order your food at the counter and pay there and then sit at a table of your choosing and wait for the food to come out. The food although was pretty tasty was very small portions for the price you’re paying for it. My stuffed shells came with 5 shells on the plate for $19… bit overpriced in my opinion for the fact that this is not a traditional sit down restaurant and you don’t get much food.

I randomly discovered this neighborhood gem while in the area. This is a real gem with very thoughtfully crafted dishes. A relleno is usually stuffed with cheese, battered, and friend. In this case, the ingredients and sauces and preparation really elevated the dish. It was very “up market” and I cleaned the plate. An excellent vegetarian option. The peach tart looked beautiful and had potential but fell short. It was overcooked. The peaches were sliced thin and beautifully arranged on top but lacked flavor and were dried out - likely due to the tart being overcooked. I’ll chalk this up to a rare miss. Service was warm and friendly. The atmosphere blended being approachable while also elevated. Prices were substantial but the food backed it up. Candidly I don’t know what’s overpriced

Went for a date right. Really fabulous food, drinks and service. Main was a gorgeous pork chop (and I'm not a pork person!) We also thoroughly enjoyed the Ceasar salad, green beans and pasta appetizer dishes. The Ceasar salad was the best I've ever had (and I am a Ceasar salad girl lol). Overall would love to return!

Excellent food with excellent service in a cozy space that is not trying too hard. We continually come back here to celebrate anniversaries and birthdays. The seasonal menu rotates so it feels new and exciting every time.