The Pie Store

Didn't know they closed for two weeks ago had very limited supply. But bought the large turkey pie-sososo good. Fyi a frozen one that has been defrosting all day takes almost 2 hours to cook, not one! Yes expensive, but such a treat! One large pie easily feeds 4 people

“The Pie Store” is an absolute gem! If you haven’t been, you’re seriously missing out on a slice of heaven—pun totally intended. Every time I walk in, I’m hit with the warm, comforting aroma of freshly baked pies, and I know I’m about to experience something special. Their chicken pie is a revelation—savory, perfectly seasoned, and packed with tender, flavorful chicken wrapped in a golden, flaky crust that’s sheer perfection. It’s the ultimate comfort food, whether you’re having it for lunch, dinner, or just because you want something amazing. And don’t get me started on their apple pie. It’s everything you dream an apple pie should be—sweet, tangy apples, a touch of cinnamon, and a buttery, crumbly crust that melts in your mouth. It’s the kind of pie that feels like a warm hug on a cris

It has been far too long since I stepped foot into this Montclair Staple. After a long day out playing music out in the cold I Pulled a quick U-turn And walked into the This little piece of Montclair Magic. Greeted by a warm smile, and an all too familiar face; I inhaled The pleasant smell of multiple pies cooking. It’s what you would imagine Bilbo Baggins little hobbit hole would smell like. Pastry, butter, sautéed onion. Van Morrison playing in the back ground. After a quick perusal of the candy section I got myself a Shepard’s pie and a Chicken Pot pie. Home now in my sweats and wool socks with a movie on and glass of Cabernet I’m so grateful for my purchase. The Shepard’s pie is ever so slightly less seasoned so that one can add salt and pepper to their liking. I brush a little melted

We’ve always wanted to try a mince pie, and this year I finally went for it . I got a mince pie from the pie store and it was absolutely delicious! So fresh, baked perfectly, with such tasty filling, my whole family loved it. Just had to put it in the oven for 15 mins and done! The whole place has such a pleasant vibe, from their chicken pot pie to apple pie everything is great!

Their key lime pie was my favorite ever. Thick but not sweet cream on top, rich and tart middle layer with satisfying lime shavings, and a buttery graham cracker crust. Also tried a strawberry scone, and a steal ale & mushroom pie, both looked amazing and tasted merely good. So, 4.5 stars, rounded up to 5 since my girlfriend, who shared all these with me, seemed outraged that I considered anything other than 5. Other notes: -All items bought cold, need to be warmed up at home. -Maximum 4 people inside at a time, and there was a slow moving line since some orders were large.