The Original NY Style Pizza & Italian Restaurant, Broomfield, Colorado

1st time here. We had a big party and they took our orders and had our food out within 15-20min period. Antipasta salad was big. Enough to feed atleadt 4 people and the thin crust pizza had a nice flavoring.

The food is awesome. Quintessential neighborhood restaurant and very authentic Italian food. Family and friend run. Kids are the servers and and one can tell the chef and cooks have generations of experience. The authenticity is real. Two thumbs up. Got a pizza and canzone. Crust on the pizza was spot on. They know what they are doing.

We’ve been here several times since discovering it - a good option for Italian. Great service, everyone was very friendly! Parking - plenty of parking in a lot. Food - The best seller (pizza) - got twice now, once dining in and once to-go. Dine in was great and cooked well. To-go was disappointing as it was quite undercooked. Would give it another shot. When we ordered to-go, the employee said to order it as a custom pizza since we didn’t want mushrooms (which is cheaper than ordering it as the best seller with a substitution). Overall rating 3.5/5. The sizzler (pizza) - delicious with the garlic (if you love garlic, it’s a must try). Tried once during dine in. Would get again. Overall rating 4/5. Baked ziti - good but very cheesy. The sauce and ziti tasted great. Definitely shareable

We ordered the eggplant parmigiana and there was only 1-2 thin layers with cheese and sauce piled on top. I tried to be positive about it but after finishing it I asked the waitress if this is the usual amount of eggplant typically in the dish. She offered to remake the dish with more layers but I declined. She took $5 off our check. I’m still wondering if that’s the way the dish is always made or if it was a bad day in the kitchen. The pizza looks amazing so we’ll definitely go back to try that. Also it was pretty Smokey inside the dining area.

We picked up pizzas for a large group activity. They were super kind, we had to wait a little bit for the pizza but we ordered a lot. So we had no problem waiting. The owner is very nice and helpful, the workers carried the pizzas to the car was very nice. Also best cannolis I have ever had, definitely freshly made.