The Juicy Seafood Restaurant & Bar- Castleton

We had a fantastic experience at Juicy Seafood celebrating a very special birthday with a group of 30 people — and everything was absolutely seamless from start to finish. Precious and Brie were exceptional. They were organized, efficient, friendly, and incredibly attentive. Managing a group that size is no small task, but they handled it with professionalism and warmth, going above and beyond to make the evening feel special and effortless. Kudos to the kitchen as well — the food was fantastic! Everything came out timely, hot, and delicious, which is impressive for such a large party. We are truly impressed by how smoothly our entire group was taken care of and so appreciative of the whole team. It made the celebration memorable in the best way. Highly recommend!

This place had the best seafood boil ever. The Cajun seasoning was perfectly spicy and not too much. We got scallops, shrimp and crab legs with potatoes and corn. It was super filling and a perfect protein meal for the night🥹 The service was also very nice, kind and helpful servers.

I recently visited Juicy Seafood on East 86th Street in Indianapolis and had a very disappointing experience. I ordered a “build your own” seafood bag and it was terrible. There was basically no flavor at all, just clumps of seasoning sitting at the bottom of the bag instead of being mixed throughout the food. To make things worse, the waiter mixed up my order with my friend’s. I specifically asked for hot seasoning, but my bag came out mild. When I told the server about the mistake, instead of correcting the order they brought me a small side of sauce. I later realized I was charged extra for that sauce, even though the mistake was on their end and I never asked for anything additional. Another issue was the pricing. The menu listed 2 eggs for $2.99, but when I got my receipt it showed

Loved this place! Erick, my server was amazing. He made sure I received the best possible first experience. Never before have I wore gloves to eat. Eat here and you will find out why quickly! I wish I lived closer as I would make this place a regular visit. Enjoyed the whole experience! Thank you!

The food was great. The service was okay. I felt out of place. The server was more attentive to the rest of the guests more so than me. Perhaps it was because my skin is light.