The Italian Pie Shoppe

I wanted to share my incredibly positive experience with other pizza lovers. The food was outstanding, and the owner was truly inspiring. Despite her street being completely closed for five months, which has led to a significant loss of vehicle access and the closure of surrounding shops, she continues to work 60-hour weeks, always prioritizing her staff and customers. It was heartwarming to see such true perseverance. I ordered the meatballs and a deep-dish pizza. The meatballs were some of the best I've ever had, with a uniquely tasty sauce, and the pizza was truly one-of-a-kind. In a world full of pizzas, hers are truly special.

Amazing Italian pizza shop! The deep dish is amazing! Give the deep dish spinach a try, you won’t regret it! Also, if your kid loves mac & cheese, they make a great Mac & cheese pizza.

Did not have garlic as a listed ingredient. Of course they had it and added it to a pepperoni and sausage. My meat lover son was not disappointed. He ate the whole pie. I was disappointed. No leftovers💜😊

Wow, I'm amazed by the deep dish this time. We got 3 pizzas. Buffalo, bbq and the meat deep dish. Its been a while since we've been here because we had been underwhelmed around 2022 and decided to try again tonight since it was our staple pizza location from 2010 to 2018. They've clearly made some changes for the better since covid times. Perfectly cooked deep dish, slight recipe change maybe? Either way 12/10 Increased toppings vs. Our experience in the past. Major major improvement there. 👏 Excellent showing tonight and if you haven't been in a while, give them another shot to support local business. Enormous improvement.

Hit up this place for a Stuffed pizza . First time here and it didn’t disappoint. Our server was kind. The pizza was delish and the place was cute and quiet. I would definitely would eat here again if I was looking for a great pizza.