The Hill

Great place for a good moment with your loved ones. The place looks very nice. The service was good and the restaurant is spacious. The prices are normal based on the food and theme of the restaurant. Expect to spend within $50 - $100 per person based on your choices. Vast selection of wines and cocktails for all tastes. Great food. I tried the short ribs. They were tender and juicy. My wife tried arrabiata pasta, which it was good. My brother tried the NY strip, and we liked it a lot, even when I’m not a person who likes those cuts, I took a piece and it didn’t disappoint. Finally, coffee and an almond cheesecake were great. I recommend this place.

I have been to the bar to have an afterwork drink and watch a game and the bar menu provided an elevated menu that was satisfying and craveworthy without being simply fried and salty like the typical bar food one finds at a local pub. The crowd was friendly and lively and the bartenders were knowledgeable as they provided both higher level mixologist options and opinions on IPAs. I have also eaten in the dining room which is homey and gorgeous, I did not realize The Hill also hosts weddings or wedding parties but that makes sense when you see the space. I usually go out for special occasions in Manhattan or locally in Jersey City or Hoboken but we travelled to Closter specifically because of the Chef Pollingers reputation and our meals at Oceana when he was in the kitchen. The dishes are w

We celebrated our 40th anniversary at The Hill for the first time, and it was a wonderful experience. The atmosphere was warm and inviting, the food was outstanding, and our server Holly made the night feel extra special with her attentive and friendly service. A perfect place for a memorable celebration — we’ll definitely be back!

My single experience was okay, at best. I took my 8yo daughter for a date night and was looking for someplace local, but semiformal. There was plenty of available reservations 30 min before since my first choice was booked. The restaurant across the street had a valet line out to the road so I was shocked that The Hill's parking lot was only 25% filled (6:30 on a Saturday night — a bit early perhaps, but still only about 1/3 filled when we left at 8:00). After walking in, the hostess had the charm of a turnip and seemed annoyed by us having the gall to show up and bother her at work. The service for the rest of the night was exceptional (save for when I was told she could not take my app order while taking a drink order because "they like all food orders to go in at once" ... I guess we'l

Neighborhood gem in Closter! Came with a big group of friends and neighbors and had such a fun night. The steak was perfect and the cheesecake was insanely creamy (we had to do dessert). The bartender was an absolute pleasure super friendly, engaging, and honestly made the night even more fun. Great spot for date night, meeting friends, or even meeting someone new. We’ll definitely be back.