The Creekside Supper Club

Creekside is a wonderfully unique place, and particularly appropriate for a special occasion, such as a birthday. The place is lively and decorated big-time for seasonal holidays, in this case, Valentine’s Day. My Manhattan was perfectly prepared. I would recommend the stuffed walleye, as it is a generous platter. Noah, our server was very attentive and pleasant and surprised me with a birthday treat. I look forward to my next visit to Creekside Supper Club. You, too, will enjoy!

My husband and I visited Creekside Supper Club for their Christmas pop-up bar, and it was such a fun experience! This place definitely has your classic Midwestern supper club vibes. It was cozy, welcoming, and nostalgic in the best way. If you’re even thinking about going during the Christmas season, I highly recommend making the trip. The entire place was completely glammed out with decorations everywhere you looked. It was clear that a lot of time and effort went into transforming the space. It truly felt magical and festive. I also highly recommend making reservations online in advance, as it’s very popular and fills up quickly. Our server, Anthony L., was great. He had a great sense of humor, was attentive, and really added to the overall experience. As for the food: my husband orde

We enjoyed Creekside Supper Club this evening for a birthday/Halloween celebration and it did not disappoint! The decorations were so much fun! The holiday drinks were strong and yummy! Our waiter Noah had impeccable customer service. A throwback to the old mid-west supper clubs, the details like a relish tray, popovers as big as your head, delicious food were awesome and vibes were perfect! This is a can’t miss place! Looking forward to the Christmas holiday decorations!

I see why reservations for the December are tough to get! The place is decorated so fun!! One of the best Christmas ones we’ve been to. We didn’t have a reservation, you can show up at 4 when they open and get a seat in the bar, we arrived at 4:20 and had a little over an hour wait. Drinks were great, food was good and service was efficient and friendly enough. Bonus was the happy hour menu prices! You could also order from the main menu if you wanted to.

Wow. First, I was not expecting the over the top Christmas decor. It was amazing and if that were the only positive it would be worth it. This is a typical Wisconsin style supper club. Fish Fry? Yes Old Fashions? Yes. Prime Rib on weekends? The food was really good as were the cocktails. Service was spectacular. This place makes you feel right at home. Recommend that you make reservations!