The Brewster Fish House

Fantastic spot that you’ll easily miss if you’re speeding through Brewster. Doesn’t look like much, it’s small, shingled and authentically Cape, but the atmosphere and food are delish. We had the Lobster Rangoons and bowls of Chowder. The Rangoons are light, crispy, and delicious. The chowder, and I consider myself quite the chowder snob, was perfect. Creamy yet delicate with ample pieces of seafood, including clams and cod, and with pieces of potato that were diced in a size that said, “we’re part of this not just cheap filler”. If the rest of the menu shows the same thought and care in execution, I would assume that your visit will be as perfect as our lunch there was. Huge shout out to the waitstaff and kitchen staff as well. Try the Watermelon Paloma, it’s wonderful.

We stopped in here to get some appetizers and a cold drink. We got there about 5:00 and it's a good thing because by the time we left after 6:00 it was packed and people were waiting to get in. I can see why, the food is delicious and the service is great. We enjoyed the calamari appetizer as well as some delicious lobster bisque. Yes, this is the place to get lobster bisque on the Cape. This is the reason why the locals are always lined up at the door the first day they open. It's the bisque.

Nice lunch at Brewster Fish House. My wife had their fish tacos, and I had a bowl of lobster bisque. Their bisque was very creamy with nice pieces of lobster. It was nice to find this open with so many restaurants in Brewster still closed for the winter season.

Eaten here before and the food was fine. Last night however was different. I ordered the lamb special and one small part of it tasted off but the rest seemed ok. Mistake! Spent all night sick as a dog and still feel terrible. The health department needs to check out the kitchen. Service was spotty and got worse when our server figured out we weren't drinking. Only one server for the entire place as well. And while the decor is nice it's very loud. We won't be going back.

Good food. Nice place. They have a rather limited menu of around six choices. I can’t say that I loved the food but it was good enough. I did like the chocolate desert. Oh and I do have to say that they have an extensive selection of whisky and (amazingly) gin. But I have to say that $36 for a nip of Yellow Spot is (pretty) outrageous. Same price (and same comment) for some of their single malt selections. They don’t take reservations. Good enough if you are in the area