The Arena

I ordered a calzone. They put an absolutely delicious butter garlic over it. The sauce they give you in the side is ice cold and it also tastes like a pasta sauce compared to an actual pizza sauce. They overcooked the crust quite a bit as you can see in the picture. The bottom was completely black.

The chicken & seasoning was delicious. The white meat was still juicy! The breading was much better the second time, as it appeared they changed the oil. It did not have a dark brown color and off taste like the first time we went. The fries were cooked perfectly but the "fresh vegetable of the day," broccoli, seemed to have been cooking for a week, was mushy and army grey-green in color. There is no other vegetable option in the sides list. Their pizza and Greek salad were good with good portion sizes. They have the best hard & soft ice cream around, Seneca Farms & Upstate Farms respectively. The small soft cone I got was the smallest small cone I have ever had. It did not cover the top of the cone edges and was very short. The cone was not weighed and the server was not proficient at mak

Best pizza in the area if you like the brick oven style. It’s in the coolest space ever, I love how they made the old bank building design work for a resturant. The staff seems great every time I go in there and they aim to please. Obviously they care about making great food as well. You gotta try the calzones. One of Wellsville’s best places to eat for sure.

The guy who took our order really needs to improve. I almost took my family and left because I was so frustrated. I was very patient with him, but my 5 year old takes better orders when we play restaurant. He seemed like he was trying, I don’t think it was purposeful, but the incompetence was infuriating. I didn’t have much faith that our order was going to be correct. Sure enough, he somehow deleted two of our subs and came to the table to have me come back to pay for them after he deleted them. He apologized, but I had gone through the order like 3 times, and he asked me about 5x how many waters we wanted. We asked for light blue cheese on the Buffalo chicken subs and it was so heavy that my son scraped it off and there was still too much for him to eat it. Otherwise, the food was good.

Pizza, wings, and salads amazingly good! The flavors of their wings, quality of pizza toppings, and crispy gluten-free crust are all five stars! We have now been here two times in person and placed to-go pizza orders at least twice. Our guests stated that it was “the best pizza they ever had.” Also, the orders are always ready ON TIME! (Not something that I can say about other pizza places around here). Will be ongoing returning customers!