The 5 O'Clock Club

Fairly new to area and first time visiting restaurant. Overcooked shrimp and undercooked baked potatoes with non-melting butter were served at the restaurant. My husband’s walleye was tasty and well-portioned, but his baked potato was also undercooked and room temperature. We waited 50 minutes for our food. The attentive server offered to adjust the bill , but we declined and accepted a dessert of our choice. The cheesecake we chose was not fresh.

The food took SO long to prepare. We got there around 6:15 and our food didn’t come until around 7:30pm. The food was decent though. The cheese curd’s texture was a bit off, however, the buttered noodles are super good. The chocolate cake is good too! Staff were super nice.

Had the Surf and Turf. Not worth the $. Too much bacon on the stuffed shrimp, all you could taste was bacon on tuff shrimp. Steak was tasty but small. Salad sucked. Drinks (white Russians) fantastic. Service was good.

The annual all you can eat shrimp is such a great time. They offer 6 different types and then it's game on. Once the shrimp starts, it's a flow of goodness. Great service. Awesome drink options, friendly staff and great food. Highly recommend.

I really was hoping for a better experience here particularly given the positive reviews. The service was one notch above abysmal. And there were plenty of people working (so there really was no excuse for the poor service). Food was average at best but the portions were large. Prices are high. The nice atmosphere is the only high point if the meal. They do charge extra if you are paying with a credit card.