Terryville Pizza

The new owners do a great job making the food and they are much friendlier everyone that works there is very polite. Last week I had wings and pizza and both were great the wings are better than when the old owners owned it they are way crispier and the sauce is better. The calzones are better than they used to be too. 10/10

Our first time ordering here. We were hungry after a failed attempt of dinner at the hibachi buffet. Although a little pricey, we also ordered the buffalo wings, I was happily surprised by the amount of them (12) and how meaty they were! My first comment was how I enjoyed how well cooked and a bit crispy they were! The side of dressing was fine! It’s usually what pizzerias give you! The pizza was very unique and delicious! I’m glad we ordered here!

I used to genuinely enjoy this establishment years ago, but unfortunately, under the new ownership and kitchen staff, the quality has declined significantly. It’s disappointing to see what was once a hometown classic losing its standard. I recently ordered a small pepperoni and sausage pizza with light cheese and asked for it to be well done — a fairly simple request. In the past, the pizzas have often been overloaded with cheese, which is why I specifically requested light cheese. However, when I arrived home, the pizza had even more cheese than usual and was noticeably undercooked to the point that it was not edible. When I called to request a refund, I was offered the option to drive back to the restaurant or receive a two-liter soda. Given that returning would require additional time

I was told when ordering it would be 45 minutes. Two hours later it showed up ice cold and I live about a mile away. The “manager” advised me to call if it was not hot - it was not. I tried calling both numbers , on one no one would answer and then hang up without saying anything, the other number would be busy. How can they run a business doing this. If this is how paying customers are treated by their business, good luck. I don’t think I will be patronizing this establishment anymore. I would give this experience negative stars if I could. Thanks Terryville Pizza. Maybe another new owner is needed!

I haven’t been to my hometown pizza place in a while, my husband and I walked into pick up our order. The woman at the front desk had no idea we put an online order through, the pizza has gone down hill, doesn’t taste the same, not cooked thoroughly, had no taste and was absolutely bland, the Greek salad was even worse with the feta cheese being old, one closed packet of dressing and one opened leaking inside the bag. I heard there was new ownership and wanted to try it for myself, regardless of some of the harsh reviews. Needless to say, when I miss home? I’ll be heading to hometown instead, this was a very big disappointment.