Sweet Licks

Linda is an amazing hostess, ice cream was delicious; The company was even better. It's good to so feel welcome in the gayest town outside NYC. Highly recommended

Absolutely fitting that the first review I saw when I came to leave this one was about the rude owner. My friends and I came here after a day out on the island and when one of us tried to use an outlet to charge their phone on the shop’s patio while we were eating our ice cream, she chewed them out about it saying “well how nice of you to ask to use my electrical outlet” and “you should’ve charged your phone before you went to bed last night.” Super weird and inappropriate power trip, so clearly she’s bored or hurt or both. Ice cream was also extremely mid and overpriced for the record.

The worst experience. I don’t usually do this, but the owner is a total Karen one of the rudest people I’ve ever encountered. When you ask her something, she treats you like you’re mentally disabled. The ice cream isn’t even that good, and it’s overpriced. We had to wait almost 20 minutes just to get her attention because she was arguing with another customer. If you’re looking for a bad experience and Karen-style treatment, this is the place. Honestly, they should put up a sign outside that says, “Welcome to Karen’s Diner.”

Absolutely lovely. Great patio to enjoy the incredible variety of top class sweets. Gelato, cookies, prosciutto bread, signature iced coffee... Fav spot

Very yummy selection from great employees/owners. Lots of signs promoting the prosciutto bread so I’ll definitely try it next time. They were open pretty late even on a weekday.