Supremo's Pizzeria - (Callery)Evans City

I've ordered from here for take out multiple times and have never been disappointed. The food is amazing and the pizza is absolutely delicious... it's like eating candy, because it's so good you eat more than your fill. I recommend it to everyone.

Expensive as hell for the quality of food. Chicken was too obviously cheap processed meat and spaghetti was the same story. Pretty sure I payed 7 bucks for a Gatorade one time. Service and atmosphere is great though. Food does not live up to the name "Supremos" they also forgot to put silverware in the bad and had to drive back. Idk who's responding to reviews from the store but I've seen some nasty replies on bad reviews so I'm expecting the same

Pizza is very good however the prices are absolutely absurd. Pictured below is a personal pizza. Using the phone for reference you can truly appreciate how small this pizza is, it cost me $11 dollars for this hand sized pizza. I’m all for having a small portion sized pizza however charging $11 dollars for this abomination is absolutely absurd. Once more the pizza tastes great, just steer clear of the extremely overpriced personal pizza.

Recipe changed from what the always had. Big chunks of stuff in the sauce of my calzone. I ended up throwing it out. I buy from here at least once a week. But. Will not buy from here again.

Great shop, good pizza! Plus it’s not too far from the Evans City Cemetery!