Stuc's Pizza

My family and I had THE best pizza ever at Stuc’s. I was genuinely surprised at how much we all loved the deep-dish pizza. We weren’t able to eat it all, so the best part was having some delicious leftovers the next day. The staff here is superb, we didn’t have to wait long, and the bartender served a killer Old Fashioned. We don’t live in Neenah, but we’re looking forward to visiting again just for the pizza. And try the pinball!

Perhaps one of the best pizza restaurants I've visited in the past year. I needed a place to grab something to eat and open my laptop up to get some work done. This was perfect. The place is immaculate - everything was super clean. The staff was friendly and as the restaurant filled up with customers I never felt like I was unattended. Best part, the pizza was fantastic. I believe I had the Stuc's Supreme, hand tossed. I usually go with a thin crust but tried something different tonight and the 12" was baked well and was crispy throughout. Delicious. I dine in my fair share of chain establishments when traveling, and it is nice to visit (what I assume is) a family-owned establishment that conducts business with pride and excellent service. Thanks again! I'll absolutely be back for m

Both locations are amazing, slight edge to Appleton as they have bigger menu and more desert offerings. Both has a really good deep dish pizza. Coming from a person who frequents Chicago deep dish often specifically Giordano's, Stuc's is definitely worth a try. The secret is in the sauce once you have a piece thank me later.

Jason and his crew are fantastic, best pizza in the Valley. Our family usually does take out. Occasionally we eat in and the dining area/bar are great, staff very friendly and the tap beer selection is great along with a full bar. Thanks Jason and crew.

Come see Paul at Stuc's for the most amazing old fashioneds and truly some of the best pizza in town! Great service, a beautiful bar, awesome food. You can't go wrong!!! You really should try the Gator! Well here goes review 2.0 I truly miss the Gator, but Ashley, Jason, and the bar crew continue to impress with amazing drinks and incredible food! What an awesome local business. The old fashioneds are mixed stiff just like they should be and the food is fresh and amazing. Made with love and dedication.... Jason and Ashley lead a great crew. Yes, I'm biased.... but it's true! See you soon at Stuc's Neenah! Update 3.0 March 2025 You know their great when your "year in review" photo app auto-magically puts together montage of Stuc's old fashioneds!