Stephanie's Italian Restaurant

Wow wow wow this place is simply amazing was greeted the most friendly waitress ever Michelle was seated promptly and served water and delicious homemade bread .our order was taken after specials were read to us .let me tell you thier specials for the evening were awesome. The food was served very fast and hot and smelling oh so scrumptious. My gf ordered the chicken Parma in penne vodka sauce was extremely delicious and man what a beautiful portion too.i order the zuppe.de peche.over papperadelle in light marinara sauce woa it was loaded with fresh seafood with fresh unbelievable delicious pasta portion was huge love it love .and the price extremely reasonable so ever in Caldwell n.j. Stephanie's is a must try for authentic Italian food and ask for the best service Michelle truly 5 star 🌟

I have not been to Stephanie's since about 2008. This Friday night I went with my buddies. All around, great food, great service , great desserts. Byob. The Italian food was true authentic Italian food. We had lots of appetizers, and all were delicious. You can order the appetizers' family style, so we did. There was not one thing bad about this restaurant. We had 9 people. This restaurant is perfect for date night, family night , or a night with your friends. FABULOUS!

Loved it will definitely be back. The food was delicious minus 1 item my boyfriend had although he will try it again lol! So good the service was great and the food came out quickly. Aweeeee the mushroom dishes were fantastic 😋

we enjoyed our meal and the service was attentive. the hostess was welcoming and the restaurant is quaint. the food is very good and portions are large. the 4 stars because i requested to swap spaghetti for penne but the chef must have refused. and the courses were rushed, dinner served while still enjoying the appetizer. the restaurant was not busy the desserts were fantastic

We dined outside which is decorated beautifully. Staff is wonderful. The food is fabulous.. we shared the arugula salad special, I had the lobster raviolis, my friend had scallop and crab stuffing special, I finished with the berries w/ cream.. make reservations! BYOB..