Stefano's Pizzeria & Restaurant

Carthage, NY · Pizza restaurant

Rating
4.4/5
★★★★☆ 4.4
Reviews
20
Rank in Carthage
#10
of 22 restaurants
City Percentile
48%
rating percentile
Address
Stefano's Pizzeria & Restaurant, 258 State St, Carthage, NY 13619
Phone
(315) 493-0400
Website
www.stefanospizzeria.com
Status
Closed · Opens 11 AM Sat

Stefano's Pizzeria & Restaurant is a restaurant located in Carthage, NY. It is one of 22 restaurants listed in Carthage. Its 4.4-star rating matches the Carthage city average of 4.4 stars. It ranks #10 of 22 restaurants in Carthage. There are 10 photos associated with this location.

Hours

Friday11 AM–10 PM

Customer Reviews

★★☆☆☆ 2.0 Sabrina Vazquez · Nov 2025

Ordered 2 Large hot subs each about $14. The size portion of the subs is baffling! There’s ONE tiny buffalo tender on this half of my sub. The quality of food is fine for a sub shop, just ridiculously tiny portions for the price point. Ordered an appetizer combo as well, which was disappointing, marinara sauce was ice cold. Customer service was great, people were nice, the portion size is just underwhelming/small!

★☆☆☆☆ 1.0 Jam Nibsss · Aug 2025

We've been loyal customers for calamari at this restaurant, but our recent experience was disappointing. The portion size of their $15 takeout has decreased significantly, as shown in the attached photos comparing our April takeout to today's.

★★★★★ 5.0 Mark · Aug 2025

Found this place by accident on one of my road trips. My family and I greatly enjoyed the place. You've got to try the cinnamon garlic knots and the waitress was amazing full dining room and she didn't even break a sweat very professional

★★★★★ 5.0 Susan Birtch · Jul 2025

5 stars across the board! Stefano’s pizza is by far the BEST IN THE BUSINESS!! Their crust is crispy, the sauce isn’t too acidic and the cheese is to die for! A favorite for everyone in our family of 4!

★☆☆☆☆ 1.0 Ally Beers · Dec 2025

My family and I came in on a Monday night, we stood at the host stand for a while and no one greeted us which should have been the first red flag. We finally got a server, we sat down and ordered drinks we asked for just an extra minute, we did however order my child food. It took the server about 20 minutes if not more to come back to the table and ask what the 2 adults wanted. At this point we were annoyed from waiting while there was one other family in the restaurant. The waitress were sitting behind the desk talking not even looking over at us. We tried to get their attention many times we left with nothing. Absolutely will not go back.

Accessibility & Amenities

✓ Wheelchair Accessible Entrance ✓ Wheelchair Accessible Parking Lot ✓ Wheelchair Accessible Restroom ✓ Wheelchair Accessible Seating

Services

Pizza restaurantDelivery Restaurant

Top Restaurants in Carthage

NameRatingReviews
The Morning Ritual★★★★★ 4.820 reviews
Bombay Duck Pickle Cafe★★★★★ 4.720 reviews
Superior Grill★★★★★ 4.620 reviews
Golden Cheng★★★★★ 4.620 reviews
The Afternoon Scoop★★★★★ 5.012 reviews
Sahara Restaurant★★★★★ 4.520 reviews
The Church Street Diner★★★★★ 4.520 reviews
Hall Pass tavern★★★★★ 4.520 reviews
Licks On 26 Ice Cream★★★★★ 4.715 reviews
NNY Ice Cream★★★★★ 5.09 reviews

This listing is informational. Contact the business directly to verify credentials, services, and availability.