Star City Diner & Pizza Parlor

We ordered 3 things off of the menu. Two of the things we ordered didn't come with the things that were listed on the menu. We were not asked about a vegetable or soup that said came with our entree, we were only asked if we wanted fries. The appetizers are okay, they definitely tasted like typical diner food. The menu mentioned pierogies but we didn't not get any pierogies. The potato skins were good. I wish things came with sauces. No bbq for the chicken tenders and no marinara for the mozzarella sticks. The patty melt I ordered came with NO sauce, so it was very dry. It was mostly onions with a thin patty. We would have asked the waitress for sauces, but after she dropped our food off she literally disappeared. A while after waiting for the check, the hostess brought it out. We think o

HIGHLY RECOMMEND! Enjoyed an amazing dinner tonight! Barry got the beef tips and noodles . Loved the suace and the tips were so tender! I got the black diamond steak and crab cake meal. The steak was done to perfection. Medium Rare and nicely seared in tbe oustide! Unlike any other “diner” steak!! We will definitely be going back! Great prices too! And our waitress Aimee was awesome too!

Party of 6. 4 Adults and 2 children. My mom ordered soup she ate the whole bowl she said it was the best soup she has ever had out to eat. My dad ordered the chefs salad it was huge and he said it was absolutely fantastic. My husband who is firm believer in if it’s a good cooked steak you don’t need any sauce made me try a piece of his steak because it was juicy, perfectly cooked as ordered medium well, and seasoned perfectly. We called the owner over to tell her to make sure she tells the cook how perfectly it was done. Most of the faces you’ll see are familiar from another diner near by we loved seeing those faces again. They said they are treated very well there. I believe the slow reviews that we have seen prior to our visit is because they naturally cook your food which is a nice chan

I really wanted this place to be good since it’s so close to us. We ordered the special for takeout: 1 large plain pizza and 2 Italian subs. We were told 30-35 mins on the phone which was when we got there. Seemed to be a mix up and was told 2 more minutes which turned into more like 10. That’s fine, things happen- especially could be busy for a Friday night. When we got home though, the pizza was cold and seemed a bit burnt. It was cold outside, but the drive is only about 2 minutes so it couldn’t have gotten that cold so fast. The subs were smaller than expected, not a lot of meat and also no mayonnaise. Hopefully with some time things will improve but it will be awhile until we return. I was really looking forward to fulfilling some pregnancy cravings and was a let down.

My husband and I had dinner at Star City Diner in Shoemakersville, and we were blown away! My husband is an extremely picky eater — he’s a fantastic cook himself and makes an amazing chicken fettuccine Alfredo at home. Until now, he’s never found a restaurant version that even came close… but Star City finally did it. Their chicken Alfredo was flavorful, creamy, perfectly seasoned, and honestly the best we’ve ever had at a restaurant. It completely exceeded our expectations! We also had the soup to start, and it was incredible — so fresh and full of flavor. To finish, we shared a slice of apple pie, and it was absolutely delicious. Warm, perfectly spiced, and the ideal end to a great meal. From start to finish, the food was outstanding. We’re so impressed and will definitely be coming back