Stacy’s Kitchen

This place is a hidden gem! The bagels are the best I’ve had in Colorado. True New York bagels. The chocolate chip cookie and magic bar were both delicious. We ordered two gluten free Thanksgiving pies (pumpkin and pecan) and my whole family thought it was the best pie crust they’ve ever had…and most were not gluten free! Highly recommend for a quick bite, baked goods or special order pies.

Absolutely wonderful! Rebecca is a beautiful person and the entire staff are lovely!! Will be back again. Thank you for catering my loved ones' 90th bday event! 🎂 You all are a blessing. Enjoy and God bless!!! 💜

So happy to have found this spot. Actual New York bagels! I am excited to try the ultimate egg salad next time. Was a pleasure speaking with Stacy while she prepared by sandwich. It has been frustrating living in Colorado as a former New Yorker - so this brought a taste of my youth with pork roll egg and cheese on an everything bagel. Forgot to ask for a tomato on it which is how I usually got it. Thank you Stacy for bringing this to Erie!

Stacy's kitchen is the best. Great Italian sandwich, and we got 4 pies for Thanksgiving and they were all delicious. Stacy is a great person and her staff is great too

Adorable, cute sandwich shop just around the corner from Old Downtown Erie. Beautiful outdoor patio, pet friendly. Husband and I have been looking for a good sandwich shop nearby and this place delivers! Club sandwich was fantastic and the Build Your Own tasted like it was made in my own kitchen. Definitely will be returning to try other items on the menu!