Square Peg Pizzeria Shelton

First time ordering take out from here! We were at the fireworks last week & someone let me have left over pizza, so I had to come back. The pizza is light & airy with good flavor. We ordered a margarita, pepperoni, & a salad. The salad was fresh with delicious veggies. We very much enjoyed it all and plan to return to eat at the restaurant. Customer service was great as well. July 31st - we returned to eat here and it was a good experience. They were giving out fried spaghetti, it was strangely good!

Fantastic. Both the normal pie and the Detroit style were both great in different ways. Wonderful people who work here too, and the only high quality pizza place in the area open past 8pm on a Monday (another place turned us away.) Reasonably priced too. Offered me a free dessert for my birthday! Made it very special. Will definitely go here again! And again and again…

Personally would not recommend. I looked at others photos in this review section and none of theirs is nearly as burnt as the two pies we received this evening. The pizza was so burnt and not appetizing. The chicken still has feathers and I could not taste any “hot honey”. Nothing special I may give this place one more shot but for $100 idk. We ordered two large pies , Motts sticks, & wings. I’ve had better pizza.

Food was alright. Got a Detroit pizza and a buffalo chicken pizza. The Detroit pizza was very small for $27 and the buffalo chicken pizza always super thin and dry. Also tasted a bit odd. This was a one and done for me. We also got 2 orders of chicken tenders and the total bill was $87. Ridiculous!

Well I ordered a small $13. With sausage $5. And caramelized onions $3 and I’m sorry definitely not worth it couldn’t even put the right amount of cheese let alone 5$ worth of sausage and $3 worth of onions