Southold Fish Market

Delicious seafood! And lots of fresh catching the day local fish here. One of my top seafood shops on the whole Long Island. Smoker trout was amazing. Cod sandwich superb. Service is great. No wonder this pace is packed for lunch in the middle of the day. We highly recommend this place!

The best seafood I’ve had in my life!!! My first time in America and this place was exactly what I was looking for. I had a variety of oysters, cold and warm lobster roll, fried calamari, steamers, mayo mahi tacos and their New England clam chowder. Everything blew my mind. I had to get a hat so I can reminisce about this place when I’m back home. Hope I will get to visit again!

We were absolutely stunned by how good the food was at Southold Fish Market! Every bite was fresh and flavorful—true coastal perfection. The place is full of character, with that authentic seaside charm that makes you feel like you’ve discovered a local treasure. The staff were super friendly and welcoming, adding to the warm, laid-back vibe. If you’re anywhere near Southold, do yourself a favor and stop by—this spot is a gem!

"Fresh fish" best describes the food here. With indoor and outdoor seating, it never feels crowded. Today the bar is manned.

Came to this place super hungry on an early October Saturday in the late afternoon. It was busy but crowded. Easily found an open seat both indoors or outside on the picnic tables. I got the cold $31 lobster roll with fries. It was very good. Big chunks of lobster. Mayo. Celery. And the Cole slaw was really nice too. Better than the fries, which were better than average. Bar with local beer and wine options. Bloody Mary looked ridiculous with shrimp, etc. Good, fresh seafood here.